Impact of Hurricane María – Puerto Rico

Summary Report by Estudios Tecnicos as submitted to the Puerto Rico Builders Association  

Hurricane Maria made landfall in Puerto Rico on Wednesday, September 20th, with sustained winds of 155 mph and gusts of up to 175 mph, causing tremendous devastation and destruction to the island’s infrastructure.

The impact of Hurricane Maria is estimated between $53.8 and $67.6 billion – Reconstruction costs alone could total $23.0 to $28.9 billion. Lost business activity was estimated at $13.7 to $17.2 billion.

In response to the aforementioned damage, over $6 billion dollars have been injected in the island’s economy through a combination of federal relief funding, central government investment, the Red Cross, and private insurers’ disbursements.

 

Microsoft Word - Draft of Cost of Maria (rev)[1].docx

 

Given past experiences with hurricanes in Puerto Rico, an increase in GNP is expected in 2018 and 2019. 

Investment in construction would almost triple over the next two fiscal years.

Most of these reconstruction costs are related to housing units that need to be rebuilt over the coming months. Estimates place 40,000-60,000 homes destroyed and an additional 160,000-180,000 suffered minor to moderate damage.

Microsoft Word - Draft of Cost of Maria (rev)[1].docx

However, the expansion in economic activity is only temporary. After fiscal 2019, Puerto Rico will likely return to a declining trend in GNP growth, as other socio-economic indicators will likely continue to deteriorate.

 

Microsoft Word - Draft of Cost of Maria (rev)[1].docx

After 2019 that should average a negative -3.2% between 2020 and 2023. Between 2023 and 2027 1.9% growth is assumed, 2.4% between 2028 and 2032, and finally 3.0% growth from 2033 onward. The economy would reach 2006 levels by 2032.

This long recovery period is a further indicator of the massive structural damages that the economy has sustained not only from Maria but also from the prolonged economic contraction.

Economic recovery will require major structural adjustments and not simply marginal changes to improve efficiency in the public sector. 

Hurricane Effects on Caribbean Hotel Industry

The region and its hotel sector was significantly impacted by two, back-to-back, Category-5 hurricanes that tore through the northern Leeward Islands in September. Hurricane Irma had the greatest effect on the islands of Barbuda, St. Barth, Anguilla, St. Maarten/St. Martin, St. Thomas (USVI) and most of the BVI; while two weeks later Hurricane Maria mostly bashed Dominica, St. Croix (USVI) and Puerto Rico.

In Anguilla, it is reported that Four Seasons will re-open April, 2018, CuisinArt in the summer, and Cap Juluca in November of next year. Ce Blue and Frangipani can open as early as next month, and Zemi Beach is ready to open as soon as there is electric power.

sandels

 

 

In the BVI, damaged hotels with scheduled re-open dates include Scrub Island (February, 2018), Sebastian’s on the Beach (Q2, 2018) and Peter Island Resort (December, 2018). Other properties such as Maria’s, Village Cay and Nanny Cay are all already partially open. On the other hand, some of the major properties such as Rosewood Little Dix Bay (this resort was already closed for renovations), Long Bay Beach Resort and Bitter End Yacht Club are all closed until further notice.

In Puerto Rico there are many well-known tourist hotels already open for business or opening in early December, such as Ritz Carlton Dorado Beach, San Juan Marriott, Condado Vanderbilt and La Concha. Others with scheduled opening dates in January include Caribe Hilton, Condado Plaza, St. Regis Bahia Beach, Sheraton Old San Juan and Sheraton Puerto Rico. The Ritz Carlton San Juan is scheduled to re-pen in April. San Juan’s hotel inventory is therefore in relatively good shape compared to many smaller islands in the region. In the USVI, most of the larger hotel resorts were damaged. Those scheduled to open in 2018 include Renaissance Carambola (March), Bolongo Bay (June), Ritz Carlton (October), Marriott Frenchman’s Cove (December), and Westin St. John (November). Those that are closed indefinitely include Marriott Frenchman’s Reef, Caneel Bay and Sugar Bay.

In St. Maarten/St. Martin, all three Sonestas are closed until further notice, as is the Westin Dawn Beach, Divi Little Bay and Flamingo Beach, amongst others. St. Maarten’s hotel inventory appears to be the hardest hit overall in terms of percentage of rooms out of commission for the long term.

Conclusions and Forecasts

It appears that there will be a significant reduction in available rooms in this part of the Caribbean through the peak of tourist season 2018 due to hurricane damage, which will likely result in lower arrivals, but buoyed occupancy rates and average daily rates. We estimate approximately 5,000 rooms that were previously open will be closed throughout the primary tourist season of 2018 (at least through April) because of hurricane damage. Otherwise, the year 2017 was turning out to be relatively consistent with the prior year in terms of hotel statistics. Arrivals were continuing to grow, showing evidence if greater usage of nontraditional lodging options such as Airbnb, VRBO and other villa rental alternatives. There remains to be some concern with the growing number hotel rooms in inventory and the number of new projects being announced, and there is a significant increase in the number of rooms currently under construction (which are generally outside the hurricane affected areas). Growth in supply could result in a longer term decline in occupancy, especially if growth in arrivals begins to slow.

 

by James V. Andrews,  

Integra Realty Resources – Caribbean

How Puerto Rican evacuees will transform Florida and your business

hurricane-maria

Hurricanes Irma and Maria devastated Puerto Rico and left millions seeking a new place to call home. Now the effects are about to significantly impact Florida and be felt throughout New York, Illinois, Pennsylvania and other states across America.

With nearly 3.5 million Puerto Ricans planning on leaving the island (many already are here or on their way), U.S. cities undoubtedly will face a short-term burden. However, businesses could turn this into long-term advantages if they learn how to embrace the already flourishing Hispanic segment. 

Due to the proximity to the island, Florida will see the biggest influx of new residents comprised of families, business owners, doctors, nurses, lawyers, executives and other professionals, university students and more. With so many migrating within such a short timeframe, yes, it will challenge the local infrastructure, educational systems, employment rates, housing market and more. However, these fellow hard-working American citizens very quickly will begin fueling local economies, bringing more businesses and increasing diversity. They immediately will increase sales across nearly every industry — restaurants, grocery stores, retail outlets, car dealerships, banks, hospitals, colleges and so many more.

Could this swing sales as early as this holiday season? That depends on how you already view the Hispanic segment and if your marketing campaigns have been developed and executed through a culturally relevant strategy verses simple translations. Think about the significance of so many families and business owners rebuilding their lives and all the needs associated with it. If your company does not have multicultural messaging ready to embrace this market, your business surely will miss out. 

Earlier in the year, hopes were not high for fourth-quarter sales due to the perceived sluggish growth of the economy and a controversial leadership in the nation. The good news is that according to the latest report from ThinkNow, a leading Hispanic research company, Hispanics already were planning to spend 33 percent more this holiday season over last year, due to greater disposable income and better anticipated deals on technology and innovation. That number could go up, especially now with the addition of more relatives and friends from Puerto Rico moving in with or close by them. 

Approximately 1 million Puerto Ricans already live in Florida. After the disaster brought by the recent hurricanes, Puerto Ricans are projected to pass Cubans soon as the largest group of Hispanics in Florida.

By 2030, there will be a population increase of 6 million in Florida, and Hispanics will represent 30 percent of the state, according to Augusto Sanabria, president of Prospera, an economic development, nonprofit organization providing bilingual assistance to Hispanic entrepreneurs. Hispanics now constitute more than 20 percent of the state. It is estimated that 57 percent of the expected population growth will happen in counties such as Orange, Osceola, Hillsborough, Miami-Dade, and Broward, all of which already have a fast-growing Hispanic population. 

“These numbers confirm that our services are going to continue to be essential to ensure that Hispanics entering our market not only assimilate faster, but also increase their chances of succeeding in business,” said Sanabria. “These numbers don’t reflect the expected influx of business owners from Puerto Rico.”

For a successful fourth quarter and beyond, focus on the benefits of this changing market and implement these 3 key tips:

Embrace diversity: Over the decades, many corporations have thrown diversity under the rug. Is it because they are ignoring the statistics or do they think every segment responds to the same messaging? How are you planning to increase sales and assure a sustainable growth if you are neglecting the business impact that minorities, especially Hispanics, are bringing to the market place? This is a lucrative market that could enable your company to obtain a sustainable growth in the years to come.

Understand the differences: Many executives still identify the Puerto Rican community as the Mexican immigrant population. Puerto Ricans are Americans. They have U.S. passports and represent over 46 percent of the Hispanic population in Central Florida. You must get to know the new markets affecting our economy and ultimately your business. How much profit could you gain with a little extra knowledge?

Be prepared: It is estimated that 100,000 to 200,000 Puerto Ricans potentially could relocate, at least temporarily, to Florida. I strongly believe that based on the Hispanic market composition, Orlando and Tampa will be impacted the most. Puerto Rican entrepreneurs and business owners will begin fueling the local economy soon. How can you gain this loyal market?

If the Hispanic market was not on your priority list, it is time to rethink and reevaluate your marketing plan now. There is still a large population of foreign-born Hispanics, many of whom use advertising as an information vehicle to learn about brands and share their findings with others. Remember, diversity is a strong growth component of any modern city. And being adaptable is a strong asset to any successful company.

 

Hernan Tagliani , Contributing writer, Orlando Business Journal, Oct 11, 2017

 

Puerto Rico Elects to be # 51?

The current territorial status received 1.3% (6,820) votes, independence 1.5% (7,773) votes, and 97% (502,375) votes for Statehood, according to the State Election Commission.

vote art

This is the first time in Puerto Rico history that a Statehood referendum receives such an overwhelming majority of voters. 

 “The votes are what dictate what the steps to follow will be; in this case, a strong majority determined that we would reject the colony and favor statehood,” governor Ricardo Rosello said.

This process of petitioning Statehood will be effected under the “Tennessee Plan” whereby the governor will designate seven members to go to Congress and request Puerto Rico to become the 51st State.  

According to Resident Commissioner Jennifer González, the June 11, 2017 turn-out of 23% of registered voters (516,968) is in line with several states that were the last to achieved admission. 

  • Arizona – In 1911, a participation of 15,489 voters of a population of 217,000, for a 7% electoral participation.
  • Hawaii  – In 1940, 35% electoral participation.
  • Alaska – In 1946,  a participation of 16,375 voters of a population of 75,000, for a 21% electoral participation.  

 

 

 

 

Puerto Rico Has Higher Overall ADR and Occupancy than the Caribbean Market.

The Caribbean has seen five consecutive years of growth in occupancy, ADR, and RevPAR. The U.S. remains the largest feeder market.

A-Boutique hotel-01

 

It appears that even with the Puerto Rican debt crisis well underway, tourism has not been negatively impacted. This no doubt results from the economic strength of the mainland and its status as the primary source of Puerto Rico’s visitors.

The next charts display historical data for Puerto Rico and the overall Caribbean hotel market from 2010 to 2015, the most recent annual data available. General trends in occupancy, ADR, and RevPAR can be observed from these comparisons.

The past recession impacted the Caribbean and Puerto Rico to a significant degree. Declines were visible through 2010, but the market has seen strong gains since.

According to STR and CBRE Report, Puerto Rico followed this trend, with ADR growth fueling RevPAR gains in 2013, negating a slight decline in occupancy.

Microsoft Word - occupancy PR.doc
Puerto Rico Vs. Caribbean RevPAR Trends

 

Conversely, Puerto Rico’s RevPAR gain in 2014 was driven by occupancy. It is important to note that Puerto Rico generally has higher overall ADR and occupancy than the Caribbean market average.

 

PUERTO RICO PUSHING FOR HANDS OFF REDEVELOPMENT

As Puerto Rico continues to work around the $70B public debt crisis that threatens its economy, the commonwealth’s governor, Ricardo Rossello Nevares, and another key economic development official are pushing for private development that could help tip the economic scales. Gov. Ricardo Rossello said the island nation is pushing public-private partnerships to help various redevelopments in the country that will ultimately lead to job creation. With the economic crisis, Puerto Rico’s unemployment rate topped 12% as of January.

Open for business means we are going to foster economic growth and private investment,” said Manuel Laboy, secretary of economic development and commerce of Puerto Rico, during a Bisnow event focused on Latin American investment and development last week in Miami. “It means that the government needs to be out of the way.” Laboy said the government has targeted to grow tourism from being 7% of the total economy to 15% within five years. “That means that we’ll need more hotels. That means that we’ll need more facilities,” he said.

Neighborhood

Coco Beach Residences

Jay Smith, president of nFusion Consultancy, already is a believer in the Puerto Rico recovery story. His firm specializes in “broken” projects for a value-add play. “Those opportunities in the United States are virtually gone,” Smith said. “They are very thin.” The firm invested in Coco Beach, a 1000-acre oceanfront project that holds a 36-hole golf course that hosts the PGA tour. Smith told Bisnow in a previous interview that nFusion is marketing a development plan for a hotel and up to 1,000 homes as well as a small town center for a mixed-use community. “Ultimately, we’ll sell it or partner with a developer, most likely from the United States,” he said.

Because of the bond crisis, Smith said real estate values have bottomed out and are ripe for investing. That is helped by Puerto Rico having a seamless regulatory environment, much of which is run by U.S. government entities. “It’s a very similar and, seems to me, much less risky environment,” he said.

 

Puerto Rico China Investment Summit

Over the past decade, China has become an increasingly integral source of aid and foreign direct investment (FDI) for Latin America and the Caribbean. Rising levels of FDI and trade over time reflect deepening relationships between China and the Caribbean. 

 

On March 1 to March 13, 2017, a large group of business owners and senior executives from China and top regional and local stakeholders from Puerto Rico were brought together in San Juan, Puerto Rico. “It was an honor to present two of the most exciting resort projects in Puerto Rico; Royal Isabela Resort and Coco Beach Golf and Residences”, noted Adam Greenfader.

During the China-Puerto Rico Investment Forum held at the Convention Center, investors had questions not only about business opportunities but also about costs, incentives and the opportunity of being able to launch their products in the U.S. market. At a time when federal funds from Washington, D.C., are being limited and the island has been cut off from the markets, Puerto Rico’s economic development will depend heavily on its ability to attract foreign investment, Putnam Bridge CEO Nicholas Prouty explained while noting Puerto Rico’s numerous benefits as a U.S. jurisdiction.

 

Photos Below: Adam Greenfader with Governor Ricardo Rosselló, Li, and Luguang Yang Carter

Puerto Rico Opens For Business

 

 

 

 

 

The Puerto Rico Builders Association and top Puerto Rican government officials present, “Puerto Rico is Open For Business” at recent ULI event in Miami. Pictured from left to right – Adam Greenfader– Principal AG &T, Ricardo Alvarez – President of Álvarez-Díaz & Villalón| President of the ACPR, Manuel Laboy – Secretary of the Puerto Rico Department of Economic Development and Commerce Denisse Flores – Director of BDO Puerto Rico, Daniel Acosta – Daniel Acosta: Senior Vice PresidentMcCormack, Baron, Salazar Inc., José Izquierdo – Executive Director of the Puerto Rico Tourism Company. #PuertoRico#UrbanLand Institute#PuertoRicoOpenForBusiness

In an afternoon lunch session almost half of the audience had either been to PR or was doing business on the island. The message from the speakers was clear. The time is now. After almost a decade of crisis, consensus is clear, “the bottom has been hit”, and now the island is in a position to grow due to three key elements:

  1. The approval of the US Congress’ Fiscal Committee
  2. Ricardo Rosello’s local government’s clear and present focus on growing the economy
  3. Some very lucrative tax incentives like law 20/22  that has drawn over 1,000 investors

 

 

 

Puerto Rico Tourism Optimistic in 2017

SAN JUAN – Citing a 96% reduction in the number of new Zika cases since the peak in October, the Puerto Rico Tourism Co. (PRTC) is optimistic heading into 2017. The PRTC launched an educational outreach program in February to dissipate “the fears and communicate the real facts” about Zika, its newest press release reads. Collaborating with the Puerto Rico Hotel & Tourism Association (PRHTA) as well as Meet Puerto Rico, the PRTC presented it “Facts not Fear,” campaign. “Communicating the reality that Zika was not growing nearly as rapidly as the CDC had projected, the PRTC worked to change the Zika conversation, and emphasize the reality that reported cases are a fraction of what was projected. Cases are now at about 1 percent of Puerto Rico’s 3.5 million population versus forecasts that 25% of Puerto Ricans would eventually have the virus by the end of the year,” according to the Tourism Co.’s statement. “The dramatic decrease in the number of Zika cases in Puerto Rico is a testament to our integrated aggressive program to inform and disseminate the facts and allay the fears. The PRTC worked incredibly hard with the industry and health officials to communicate accurate and precise messages about Zika to the public,” Ingrid Rivera Rocafort, executive director of the PRTC, says in the published statement. “Ultimately, our team has been successful in not only educating our residents but protecting our visitors and our critical tourism industry.” Tourism annually contributes nearly $4 billion to Puerto Rico’s economy and was the first industry to come out of the island’s five-year recession, the public corporation explains in its release. “Since the start of Zika, total hotel registrations from Jan.-Sept. in 2016 are 1.6% above 2015 and 10 million passengers are expected to be welcomed by Puerto Rico airports by the end of 2016,” it reads.

Broadway star Chita Rivera, TV host Maía Celeste, baseball stars Carlos Correa and Iván Rodríguez, and Olympic gold medalist Mónica Puig also helped spread the word about how travelers can experience Puerto Rico worry-free. Medical influencers as well delivered the PRTC’s message. These included the late epidemiologist Dr. D.A. Henderson, scholar at the UPMC Center for Health Security in Baltimore, Maryland; Dr. Jason James, chief of obstetrics and gynecology at Baptist Hospital in Miami; and Dr. Joseph Rosado, a primary care and emergency care physician in Orange City, FL. In addition, the World Health Organization declared in November that the Zika virus was no longer considered an international public health emergency, the PRTC adds in its release. “Our collaborative efforts to date in 2016 have been effective in allaying fears, controlling Zika and the data backs it up,” notes Clarisa Jimenez, president and CEO of the PRHTA, assures in the written statement. “It is imperative that we keep our foot on the gas pedal and aggressively continue Tourism Co.:

A Fiscal Plan Towards Economic Recovery

Old San Juan

 

On October 14, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico submitted its Fiscal plan. Here is my summary: 

Only with a change in federal policy and a change in the trajectory of the island’s economy toward real growth, will there be money for  debt service – while not jeopardizing the Commonwealth’s ability to provide essential services. 

 

  • U..S. citizens living in Puerto Rico must receive the same level of healthcare funding as citizens living in the 50 statesThe Commonwealth Can Achieve Efficiency Gains by Consolidating Overlapping Agencies and by Further Centralizing Procurement to Capture Cost Savings
  • Complete large-scale strategic projects to improve accesses and competitiveness including the Northwest Corridor (PR-22 highway from Hatillo to Aguadilla), the redevelopment of Roosevelts Roads, and the Caguas Commuter Rail
  • Position Puerto Rico as one of the premiere travel destinations of the world for local, domestic and foreign travelers by supporting the financing of 9 hotel construction projects currently on hold
  • Attract economic development, private investment, and tourism by expanding the Port of the Americas value added zone, improving the Aguadilla airport, and expanding the Panamericano docks to attract Quantum-like mega cruise ships.

 

 

Click here to see the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Fiscal Plan : https://issuu.com/adamgreenfader/docs/fiscal_plan_v_final